Looking to boost your YouTube views? Our groundbreaking study reveals the exact facial expressions that drive clicks, backed by data from over 11,000 viral videos.
The Power of the Perfect Thumbnail Face
When MrBeast announced his thumbnail watch time skyrocketed just by closing his mouth, it sparked a crucial question: what makes the perfect YouTube thumbnail face? According to YouTube strategist Derral Eves (the mastermind behind MrBeast's success), "Thumbnail faces are the single most powerful tool in a creator's arsenal. The human brain processes faces 60,000 times faster than text, making them instant attention magnets."
But which expressions actually work? We analyzed 11,533 YouTube videos to find out.
Our Revolutionary Study: Beyond Just Top Creators
We didn't just look at the usual suspects. Our analysis covered:
- 5,592 videos from established YouTube stars
- 6,098 viral "outlier" videos from smaller creators
Why include outliers? Because viral hits from smaller channels reveal what truly drives engagement, independent of subscriber count. These are the expressions that work purely on merit.
The Top Faces of YouTube Success
Our data revealed four dominant expressions that consistently drive higher click-through rates:
- Surprise/Shock (averge 104k views)
- Wide eyes, raised eyebrows, open mouth
- Signals must-see content
- Works across all niches
- Most consistent performer in A/B tests
- Sadness/Empathy (average 80.9k views)
- Creates emotional connection
- Particularly effective in story-based content
- Drives longer watch times
- Higher comment engagement
- Focus/Concentration (average 77.7k views)
- Signals valuable information
- Dominates in educational content
- High retention rates
- Strong for tutorial content
- Confusion (average 76.7k views)
- Triggers curiosity
- Works well with mystery/revelation content
- High click-through on educational content
- Strong in reaction videos
And here is the distribution of face expressions among the youtube thumbnails:
Different Niches, Different Faces
Each YouTube category has its winning formula:
Gaming
- Joy/ Happiness 150.8K
- Surprise/shock 131.3K
- Thoughtful 123.6K
Educational
- Angry 68.9K
- Discomfort/ Pain 60.6K
- Focus/Concentration 44.5K
Entertainment
- Focus/Concentration 183.7K
- Surprise/shock 181.6K
- Thoughtful 142.8K
Tech Reviews
- Angry 164.4K
- Neutral 125.1K
Access Our Complete Dataset
Want to dig deeper? We've made our entire research dataset public:
CrazyFace AI YouTube Face Hub Here
Analyze trends, find patterns, and discover what works in your niche.
Creating Your Perfect Thumbnail Face
The Technical Formula
- Lighting: Face should be 30% brighter than background
- Position: Left two-thirds of frame
- Size: Face should occupy 25-40% of thumbnail
- Contrast: Use complementary colors for background
The Expression Formula
- Exaggerate naturally
- Match video emotion
- Test multiple variations
- Keep eyes focused on viewer
Introducing Crazy Face AI: Perfect Expressions, Every Time
Transform your thumbnail game with our new AI tool.
- Adjust expressions instantly
- Natural-looking results
- Based on our viral video data
- One-click optimization
Study conducted January 2025. Based on actual performance data from YouTube Analytics.
Did you find this helpful? Share it with a fellow creator!